Is this your pizzeria? Claim your profile to update your menu, respond to reviews, and upload photos.
Claim This ListingPapa's Tomato Pies
Robbinsville, NJ
About this shop
The oldest family-owned, continuously operated tomato pie restaurant in the United States. Famous for its crispy Trenton-style crust and local specialty Mustard Pie.
Order Now
Photos
Illustrative preview images. These are visual representations and are subject to change.
Community reviews
- PizzaListAdmin10/8/2026
Absolute bucket-list pizza experience. If you’ve never had a true Trenton-style tomato pie before, Papa's is the golden standard. The crunch on the ultra-thin crust is perfect, and having the sweet, vibrant tomato sauce layered right on top of the cheese makes every single bite incredibly flavorful. We also ordered the legendary Mustard Pie out of curiosity, and it blew us away—the subtle tanginess of the mustard baked right into the crust works beautifully. The family history shines through in both the service and the food. A true historic landmark that everyone needs to visit at least once!