The Pizza List
Wood-fired pizza oven

Best Utica Tomato Pie Pizza in Utica

1 local pizzeria serving Utica Tomato Pie pizza. Community-rated shops appear first; unrated kitchens follow.

Utica Tomato Pie Pizzerias

Highest rated first
O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - Authentic Pizza in Utica, NY | The Pizza List (Illustrative preview)Illustrative preview

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria

Utica, NY

Leave a Review

Founded by Eugene Burline over a century ago, this Utica institution is famous for its original upside-down tomato pies where cheese goes under the rich sauce.

Utica Tomato PieUpside Down
Dine-InTake-Out