The Absolute Best Pizza in Brooklyn, Ranked
5 local pizzerias. Community-rated shops appear first; unrated kitchens follow.
Pizza Places in Brooklyn
Highest rated first
Illustrative previewDi Fara Pizza
Midwood, Brooklyn, NY
Established in 1965 by Domenico DeMarco, Di Fara is famous for legendary classic New York style round and square pan slices topped with fresh hand-snipped basil and imported olive oil.
Illustrative previewL'Industrie Pizzeria
Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY
An iconic Williamsburg destination widely celebrated for its light, airy, long-fermented classic New York slice crusts combined with gourmet Italian toppings like fresh burrata and hot honey.
Illustrative previewLucali
Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, NY
Established in 2006 by Mark Iacono, Lucali is a candle-lit brick oven destination renowned for crispy thin-crust pies and fresh calzones. Note: Cash only and BYOB (Bring Your Own Beverage).
Illustrative previewNate’s Detroit Pizza
Brooklyn, NY
Nate’s Detroit Pizza is a local pizzeria in Brooklyn, NY. They are known for their golden, crispy crust layers and a menu packed with savory combinations. It is the perfect choice for a casual family dinner or a quick weekend slice on the go.
Illustrative previewTotonno's Pizzeria Napolitana
Brooklyn, NY
A legendary Coney Island monument serving brick-oven, coal-fired Neapolitan pies composed of daily fresh dough and fine imported Italian tomatoes since 1924.