The Pizza List
Wood-fired pizza oven

Best New York Style Pizza in Brooklyn

2 local pizzerias serving New York Style pizza. Community-rated shops appear first; unrated kitchens follow.

New York Style Pizzerias

Highest rated first
Di Fara Pizza - Authentic Pizza in Brooklyn, NY | The Pizza List (Illustrative preview)Illustrative preview

Di Fara Pizza

Midwood, Brooklyn, NY

Leave a Review

Established in 1965 by Domenico DeMarco, Di Fara is famous for legendary classic New York style round and square pan slices topped with fresh hand-snipped basil and imported olive oil.

New York StyleSquare Pan
Dine-InTake-Out
L'Industrie Pizzeria - Authentic Pizza in Brooklyn, NY | The Pizza List (Illustrative preview)Illustrative preview

L'Industrie Pizzeria

Williamsburg, Brooklyn, NY

Leave a Review

An iconic Williamsburg destination widely celebrated for its light, airy, long-fermented classic New York slice crusts combined with gourmet Italian toppings like fresh burrata and hot honey.

New York StyleBurrata Pie
Dine-InTake-Out